DVDex

Technically Creative or Creatively Technical

November 21, 2026, by Justin Yates

Not long ago I got into an argument with someone who has been making film and television for a long time and is very good at it.

Their position was that they aren't interested in the technical side, only the creative. Paying attention to the tools, the software and the technique, they said, takes the romance out of the craft. Things should be done by hand. The line that stuck with me was this one: "I don't want a script to do my job for me."

I've been turning it over since. I don't think they're wrong about what they love. I think they're wrong about where the line is.

Artists are technical people

The most creative people I've worked with are also the most particular about process. They care which lens, which take, which frame. They have rules about how the room is set up and what order things happen in. Ask a painter about brushes, or a musician about their instrument, and you'll get an hour of detail that sounds a lot like engineering.

We don't usually call that technical. We call it craft. But it's the same instinct: a strong opinion about how the work gets made, held by someone who knows that the how changes the what.

Cutting film by hand was technical too. Splicers, grease pencils, trim bins and sync blocks were the technology of their day, and the editors who used them well were proud of their technique. The romance came from mastering those tools, and there were plenty of them.

Chicken and egg

Which comes first is harder to say. Sometimes an idea sends you looking for a technique that can pull it off. Sometimes a technique shows you an idea you wouldn't have had. A new way of doing something changes what occurs to you to try.

I don't think there's one answer, because people are built differently. Some editors come at a scene through feeling and find the method afterwards. Others get their hands on the material first and let the feeling arrive through the work. Most of us go back and forth all day without noticing.

So when someone tells me they're only interested in the creative, I believe them about their own experience. I just suspect there's more technique in what they do than they'd call by that name.

What I automate

As for a script doing my job: I don't want that either.

What I want a script to do is the part that isn't my job. The renaming, the relinking, the list that has to be made the same way every time. None of that is where a cut gets better. All of it sits between me and the moment when I can try something on a whim and see if it plays.

That's why I build tools. I automate the things that get in the way of my ability to improvise, and I keep the improvising for myself.

Justin

All posts